Dear all,
We have got a reply to our comments concerning the paper: LHCB-PAPER-2012-051-001.
https://cds.cern.ch/record/1514042?
I do not find their answers completely satisfactory in some parts, but at least they have removed the problem of the mid-q^2 bin by merging it to the rho/omega region.
I don't have other major concerns, let me know if you want to comment back something.
cheers, Francesco
On Thursday 07 Feb 2013 11:21:11 Francesco Dettori wrote: |Dear all, | |since I didn't get any reply I've posted on CDS our comments on the paper |this morning. | |cheers, | Francesco | | |---- Forwarded message ---- | ||Dear LHCb Colleague, || || Your comment: document LHCB-PAPER-2012-051-001-COMMENT-004 has || been || ||correctly received. || ||It will be soon added to our Document Server. || ||The comment may be found at this URL: http://cds.cern.ch/record/1508066 ||It may also be viewed from the link 'View the N comments' of the document ||LHCB-PAPER-2012-051-001-COMMENT-004 (entitled: 'A search for $D^+_{(s)} \to ||\pi^+\mu^-\mu^-$ and $D^+_{(s)} \to \pi^-\mu^+\mu^+$ decays'). || ||If you detect an error please let us know by sending an email to ||cds.support@cern.ch. || || || ||Thank you for your comments. | |On Thursday 24 Jan 2013 15:04:22 Francesco Dettori wrote: || Dear all, || ||in attachment you can find a summary of the comments on the paper on D-> pi ||mu mu. So far it includes Patrick and Kristof's comments, beside mine. If ||anybody else wants to add other comments I'll integrate them. ||If not Tjeerd would you upload them on behalf of the group? || || cheers, || Francesco || ||-------------------- || || Francesco Dettori || NIKHEF || +31 20 592 2230 (Nikhef) || +41 22 76 76284 (CERN) || fdettori@nikhef.nl || francesco.dettori@cern.ch || ||-------------------- | |-------------------- | Francesco Dettori | NIKHEF | +31 20 592 2230 (Nikhef) | +41 22 76 76284 (CERN) | fdettori@nikhef.nl | francesco.dettori@cern.ch |-------------------- |_______________________________________________ |Bfys-physics mailing list |Bfys-physics@nikhef.nl |https://mailman.nikhef.nl/mailman/listinfo/bfys-physics
-------------------- Francesco Dettori NIKHEF +31 20 592 2230 (Nikhef) +41 22 76 76284 (CERN) fdettori@nikhef.nl francesco.dettori@cern.ch --------------------