Hallo all, I read the article some time ago and let it pass: my opinion about it was that of Oscar Naviliat. However, I know Atilla and he is not a joke. He cleaned up the improvised act of the early measurements considerably, he got rid of all bumps and did not get the last one....

Just to recall the past: There is also an article in Nature of this sort by Rudi van Dantzig en Fokke de Boer that was highly lauded by the editor. Also that one passed without trace.

The question is how does this boson so effectively compete with normal EM and why has it not been seen in other studies of e+e- in nuclear decays. It kind of surprises me that the theoreticians have nothing to say about that. It should be possible to say something about the coupling strength.

Hans

Hi Patrick, Gerco,

But the only complaint is that the disappearance of the
previous claims from Fokke de Boer at 12 and 13.45 MeV
is not explained?

I don't read any strong objections against the present
experiment itself? (Apart that they would have wished for a blind analysis?)

Cheers, Niels

_______________________________________________
Bfys-physics mailing list
Bfys-physics@nikhef.nl
https://mailman.nikhef.nl/mailman/listinfo/bfys-physics